Practical Economics


The End of the Credit Crunch

Richard DeKaser

Access to business loans is about to get easier.



Business access to bank loans is poised to improve as lenders get losses under control and upgrade their economic outlook, while borrowers strengthen their financial condition. The result will be a virtuous circle: easier credit stimulating economic activity, which feeds back to still easier credit. This can’t go on forever, of course. But the self reinforcing dynamic has at least a year to run.

First, let’s get the bad news out of the way: Bank losses remain huge. The industry racked up a whopping $187 billion in losses last year, amounting to 2.9% of loans outstanding—greater than any time since 1934. About the best that can be said is that the rate at which losses are increasing slowed during the course of the year, and a plateau seems to be taking shape.

What’s more important, however, is that banks beefed up their barricades against further damage. The industry’s first line of defense against insolvency—loan loss reserves—stood at 3.1% of loans outstanding as this year began. That’s greater than any time since 1934, when the FDIC began keeping such records. And the last line of defense—bank equity capital—also improved, despite the repayment of three-quarters of the funds the government poured into banks and financial corporations to avoid a meltdown in 2008. (The federal assistance was repaid at a handsome profit to the American taxpayer, by the way.) At 11%, the industry’s equity-to-asset ratio stands at its highest since 1938. These substantial cushions are one reason the purse strings are likely to loosen this year.

Banks are taking heart from the nascent economic recovery, though they remain prepared for the worst. The Federal Reserve reported that in January, for the first time since early 2007, the percentage of banks tightening terms on business loans was nearly offset by an equal number of them easing lending terms. Sixty percent of the banks that did relax loan terms cited a “more favorable or less uncertain economic outlook.”

Advertisement

This growing optimism (or, more fairly, diminished pessimism) is largely rooted in the improving financial condition of their customers. As I noted last week, businesses have been stockpiling cash. The resulting liquidity bolsters lender confidence that short-term loans will hold up well. And with the recent stabilization of property values, banks now have greater certainty when assessing the collateral backstopping longer-term loans.

The impending ease won’t be geographically uniform, however. Community banks in states with more severe economic hangovers, including those coping with auto sector restructuring (Michigan, for example) and the real estate bust (including Florida, California, Nevada and Arizona) are struggling with higher loss rates and intense regulatory scrutiny that will likely be slow to thaw. As Cam Fine, president of the Independent Community Bankers of America, puts it: “The economies of those states are struggling, and the bank examination atmosphere has been so severe in the past two years that many bankers have decided to simply hunker down and not go out on a limb.”

If my prediction of an imminent easing of bank lending holds up, two developments will soon confirm it. First, the next Federal Reserve survey of lending officers will show a majority of respondents easing their terms on business loans—the first such occurrence in three years. This survey is now under way and will be available during the first week of May.

Second, a monthly survey conducted by the National Federation of Independent Business will show a sharp drop in participants claiming that loans are “harder to get.” As of February, 12% more survey respondents said loans were harder to get than those who said credit was easier to secure. While that’s an improvement over last year—when, in May, a net 16% of respondents said lending was tougher to come by than three months earlier—a 12% margin is still symptomatic of very tight conditions. Normally, that figure would range between 3% and 9%.

Aside from the obvious implication -- that creditworthy businesses won’t have as tough a time with their bankers -- this easing of credit is also critical to the economic outlook. The federal stimulus is set to wind down around year-end, and the private sector will increasingly be required to keep the momentum going. Additionally, broader lending will be an important precondition for any change in monetary policy: It’s hard to imagine the Fed hiking interest rates or draining money from banks when lenders still aren’t doing their job.




You can get valuable updates like Practical Economics from Kiplinger sent directly to your e-mail. Simply enter your e-mail address and click "sign up."

More Sponsored Links


DISCUSS

Permission to post your comment is assumed when you submit it. The name you provide will be used to identify your post, and NOT your e-mail address. We reserve the right to excerpt or edit any posted comments for clarity, appropriateness, civility, and relevance to the topic.
View our full privacy policy


Advertisement

Market Update

Advertisement

Featured Videos From Kiplinger